Sunday, November 15, 2026

BE CAREFUL ABOUT BECOMING A PLATEAU TEACHER

Several years ago, I was invited to speak to a group of high school teachers who were holding a meeting in Savannah, Georgia.  I flew down to Savannah.  The meeting was held at a hotel near the airport, so I was able to do my presentation and then fly home. 

I arrived at the facility early and met several of the participants.  They were all young teachers at the very beginning of their careers.  They were so wonderfully excited and eager.  They did not come to the conference just to enjoy Savannah.  They wanted to learn more about teaching.  They wanted to become great teachers, the kind of teachers that students would always remember.  They wanted to be teachers who helped transform the lives of their students.  They were eager for advice and guidance. 

As a result, I adjusted my presentation a bit to address their desire to grow and become better.  I talked about Malcolm Gladwell’s book Outliers.  In it, he makes the astute observation that in most tasks such as playing the guitar or competing in chess or learning to teach, people start out quickly becoming better but eventually the improvement slows down and eventually stops. Most chess players simply get to a point where they stop getting better.  The same applies to teachers.  Most get to some level, a C level, for example, or a B+ level, and they never really improve much after that.  That is who they become as a teacher.  I refer to them as “Plateau Teachers.”   They might be doing well but the improvement has stopped.  I knew teachers 40 years ago who were (in my judgment) B teachers and they stayed at that level until they retired.

That day in Savannah, I looked at those bright young teachers and gave them my most adamant advice, “Don’t ever become a plateau teacher.  Don’t ever stop working to improve.  Continue to experiment.  Take risks and see what works.” 

I followed that admonition with a teaching quote I often use, “Great teaching does not come from years of doing it.  Great teaching comes from years of thinking about it.”  For me, those words are practically a holy statement.  The key, in my mind, to avoiding the teaching plateau is to have enough ambition that you think obsessively about what you can do to make your class go better.

Do you really want to improve over the next 6 months or so?  Here’s one technique you might try.  Make a list of every aspect of the teaching system that you are designing.  Open your mind and think about any and every decision you must make.

--How many tests do you want to give?

--What is your policy on absences and how do you enforce it?

--How much time do you want your students to spend systems between classes?

--Are 50 minute classes or 75 classes better for your students?

--How do you help them know what to do between classes?  (Do you just tell them to study without any guidance as to what that means?)

--Do you care where the students sit?

--How much talking do you want the students to do in class?

--What will you do if a good student starts to become a bad student?

--How do you get the students to talk as much as you would like in class?

--How do you communicate with your students and how do you make sure they actually listen?

--How do you motivate students?  Do you use carrots or sticks?

--What attitude do you want your students to have toward you?  What attitude do you want them to think that you have toward the class?

--What is an appropriate grade distribution?  Grade inflation creates problems but does have some advantages.

--In class, how do you prevent students from becoming invisible, students who never speak but simply take notes, memorize, and hide.

--How many office hours should you have?  Why would a student have a need to come to your office hours?  (Probably 40 years ago, I rearranged the furniture in my office to make it more inviting to the students.  I also began to add odd decorations to the office to provide us with something to talk about if that was needed.)

--Are you providing them with an education that is worth what it costs?

--How do you want your students to be different on the last day of the semester than they were on the first day of the semester?

I refer to all of these contemplations as creating my person teaching system.  It might not work for anyone else, but I’m trying to develop a system that works for me and my personality. 

Then, like monitoring a finely turned luxury automobile, I pay close attention to everything that goes on.  What is working?  What is not working?  Where are changes needed?  What happens that is unexpected?  What worries you?  What are the current class problems and how do I address them without damaging the rest of the system?

College teaching can absolutely be the most interesting job in the world, but it requires a system that helps each of us continue to improve and not wind up as plateau teachers.

I gave that talk in Savannah many years ago.  I wonder how many of those young teachers kept improving and had fantastic careers and managed to avoid becoming plateau teachers.  Hopefully, all of them.  That’s why I went down there.

**

For a free download of my new book, “100 Conversation Starters to Develop Student Critical Thinking in Intermediate and Financial Accounting Courses,” just go the University of Richmond Scholarship Repository at the following link.  To date, the book has been downloaded more than 1,470 times.  I appreciate greatly everyone who has helped to spread the word. 

https://scholarship.richmond.edu/bookshelf/400/

 



No comments:

Post a Comment